In his order, Judge Bernard Jones called Walters’ justifications “little more than a ruse, masking an effort to punish a news organization for its editorial stance.” Judge Jones also wrote, “The right to free speech is a fundamental prerequisite to the success of the republic. This, no doubt, is what separates this country from authoritative regimes, where government control over information and the press stifles public discourse and suppresses dissent.”
The right to freedom of the press, which covers both individual citizen journalists and media like KFOR, serves as a vital check on government power. When government officials upset about an outlet’s coverage deem it “illegitimate,” they damage the media’s essential function in a healthy democracy — all while violating the First Amendment.
Judge Jones’ words provide a vital lesson for Superintendent Walters. As the state’s top education official, Walters should champion the principles enshrined in our Constitution, not undermine them. He has set a terrible example for Oklahoma’s K-12 students.
How can we expect Oklahoma’s children to understand and value constitutional rights when those in charge of their education disregard those freedoms? We’ve seen too many college students lately showing little regard for free speech, with cancellations of speakers and disruptions of guest speakers. Such bad habits are not suddenly learned in college lecture halls.
Walters’ behavior also creates practical damage. Ironically, the topic of the first meeting KFOR journalists were able to cover after the judge’s order concerned the education budget request. Walters’ irresponsible actions have already diverted scarce tax funds and threaten to divert more to fight a losing battle in court and force state attorneys to defend the indefensible. Federal law also provides for payment of attorney’s fees for plaintiffs who have had to sue to vindicate their rights.
Unfortunately, the response so far from Walters’ office reflects a disregard for this and other problems created by his stance, with Isett continuing his ill-advised barbs at KFOR and mischaracterizing the judge’s ruling as “giving” the station “privileges.”
First Amendment rights aren’t privileges given by judges. Our Constitution doesn’t let government officials decide what is “legitimate” news or opinion.
The lesson for Superintendent Walters and us all is clear: The First Amendment isn’t optional. It’s the bedrock of our democracy. And those who take an oath to uphold the Constitution, such as Walters, must be its first defenders, not its adversaries. That’s a lesson worth teaching in every classroom across Oklahoma — and the nation.
I hope Superintendent Walters will take this opportunity to reflect on the judge’s excellent opinion and learn more about the First Amendment. This incident should serve as the ultimate “teachable moment” both for students and the highest state official entrusted to teach children.
